Another successful quarter of teaching has come to an end. Usually I go on about the miseries of teaching and how disappointing the students were, etc. etc. Instead I'll focus on the positive; again this quarter, my students have outperformed the other TA's sections. This has happened often enough that I should no longer consider it a fluke. The difference is small, my students' average bested the other two sections by 30 pts and 10 pts respectively, where the classes' individual standard deviation was 140 points (all graded out of 1000 total points). I'm not a statistician, but I think consistently beating the other sections for 6 out of 6 quarters, even by small margins, means something.
The secret? Not coddling the little snots: tough love and high expectations along with a bit of attentiveness. This is college, not the 4th grade. I tell the stupid ones they're stupid and the smart ones that they're not trying hard enough. At the end of the quarter I get glowing TA reviews from them. The public loves me, and sometimes, I might even say that I'm proud of them.
Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts
March 23, 2009
January 20, 2009
Reike Magnesium (Mg*)
In order to get my Grignard reactions to work even a little bit, I've been heating them considerably. This was fine when I was working in THF, as I would usually heat them to 70 C or so. The bomb flasks I'm using can handle the extra pressure (THF boils at 65 C). Now I'm using diethyl ether as a solvent to prevent activation of the alpha hydrogen in THF; unfortunately this means I'm restricted to lower temperatures. I tried to calculate the pressure I would build up in the flask while heating the ether to 70 C. I didn't get the number exactly, but suffice to say it's more than I'm comfortable with having in my hood. So the next great idea is to lower the required temperature by using "highly activated magnesium powder" also known as Reike Magnesium. (The abbreviation commonly used is Mg*.) This is made simply by reducing Mg-dihalide to elemental magnesium using a strong reductant, usually an alkali metal. The easiest way I can see to make this is to stir up the MgCl2 with potassium metal in THF while refluxing. Potassium melts at a slightly lower temperature than THF boils, so the molten potassium reacts quite easily with the MgCl2.
Rieke Magnesium is called such because Ruben D. Rieke has championed this form of magnesium as a route to generally inaccessable Grignard reactions. He has also commercialized this process, you can see his outfit here if you like. I browsed the website myself, and noticed a little grammatical mistake that I'll now make light of.
Often times my students, and occasionally even my well learned labmates, will do what is called "verbification". (This word actually shows up in several on line dictionaries now, very depressing) That is, they take a noun and use it as a verb to imply action of the noun on a subject in an obvious manner. One of the most common nouns which is subjected to verbification in the lab is "cannula", a long metal tube used to transfer liquids between reactions vessels while excluding the outside atmosphere. Often the transfer process is reffered to by the slur "cannulate". This appears in Rieke's website...
No need for a drybox or a solvent still. Simply cannulate Rieke® Metals in THF into a reaction flask under an atmosphere of argon or nitrogen.
I have been telling my students (and labmates) that "cannulate" is not a word, although you can in fact transfer something using a cannula. I was amused to see this grammatical miscue on a commercial website. Upon further investigation it turns out "cannulate" is actually a word, but it refers to the act of puncturing with a cannula, not transfering a vessel's contents. A near-miss for the author's of Ruben's website, but a miss for sure. As I tell my students quite often while they struggle to pronounce words like meridional, molybdenum, mesitylene; part of being educated is sounding educated.
Rieke Magnesium is called such because Ruben D. Rieke has championed this form of magnesium as a route to generally inaccessable Grignard reactions. He has also commercialized this process, you can see his outfit here if you like. I browsed the website myself, and noticed a little grammatical mistake that I'll now make light of.
Often times my students, and occasionally even my well learned labmates, will do what is called "verbification". (This word actually shows up in several on line dictionaries now, very depressing) That is, they take a noun and use it as a verb to imply action of the noun on a subject in an obvious manner. One of the most common nouns which is subjected to verbification in the lab is "cannula", a long metal tube used to transfer liquids between reactions vessels while excluding the outside atmosphere. Often the transfer process is reffered to by the slur "cannulate". This appears in Rieke's website...
No need for a drybox or a solvent still. Simply cannulate Rieke® Metals in THF into a reaction flask under an atmosphere of argon or nitrogen.
I have been telling my students (and labmates) that "cannulate" is not a word, although you can in fact transfer something using a cannula. I was amused to see this grammatical miscue on a commercial website. Upon further investigation it turns out "cannulate" is actually a word, but it refers to the act of puncturing with a cannula, not transfering a vessel's contents. A near-miss for the author's of Ruben's website, but a miss for sure. As I tell my students quite often while they struggle to pronounce words like meridional, molybdenum, mesitylene; part of being educated is sounding educated.
February 29, 2008
dealing with English
Where has our fearless blogger been off to? At war with the English language.
After a good solid month of struggling with this paper its finally off to the co-authors. All told there is 30 pages of melt-in-your-mouth scientific jargon and nonsensical tables filled with roman numerals, Greek letters, and some special characters that don't even have names. (This is a lie of course, but few people outside chemistry have reasonable cause to know what an angstrom is or what the symbol for it looks like. Many wouldn't know what an ampersand was if not for "Wheel of Fortune")
More to the point, although the paper has not been accepted it is not in danger of being rejected as was the previous paper I wrote. Now it's just a question of where it will be published after its been reviewed etc. etc. Our first try will be to the Journal of the American Chemical Society, which is the most prominent chemistry journal globally. There are those (mostly Europeans) who may contest that Angewandte Chemie should have that title, but most people I know only publish in Angewandte after JACS has rejected their paper.
Actual publication is still a far way off. I suppose I am at the stage that can be considered "2nd draft". There will be a 3rd draft after the co-authors have their say at which point it will be sent to the journal, which will send it out to referees for peer review. After the referees comment on it (assuming it is accepted) there will be a "1st revision" which will be sent back to the journal. The journal typesets the paper at which point it becomes a "Galley Proof" and then publication.
So it would seem that this particular battle with the English language has been won; however, while writing my own paper I have had to spend a lot of unfortunate time reading written reports for the class that I'm TA'ing. This battle has been largely lost I feel, and not solely because of the ESL students. The native speakers have acquired a keen disregard for all things grammatical and pay no mind to spelling or word choice. I try to focus on the English for the written reports because most of the time, their chemistry is even worse. This exercise has been thoroughly demoralizing. I threw away the standard rubric for a much more holistic grading scheme which consisted of "unacceptable" "needs improvement" and "satisfactory". So far only one student in 30 has received a grade of satisfactory.
With all this done I turn my attention to other matters. We have just received shipment of our new belt-drive vacuum pumps, which means that we can begin setting up the new Schlenk lines. Hopefully this will provide some material for the blog (including pictures for those of you who need some breaks from reading.)
After a good solid month of struggling with this paper its finally off to the co-authors. All told there is 30 pages of melt-in-your-mouth scientific jargon and nonsensical tables filled with roman numerals, Greek letters, and some special characters that don't even have names. (This is a lie of course, but few people outside chemistry have reasonable cause to know what an angstrom is or what the symbol for it looks like. Many wouldn't know what an ampersand was if not for "Wheel of Fortune")
More to the point, although the paper has not been accepted it is not in danger of being rejected as was the previous paper I wrote. Now it's just a question of where it will be published after its been reviewed etc. etc. Our first try will be to the Journal of the American Chemical Society, which is the most prominent chemistry journal globally. There are those (mostly Europeans) who may contest that Angewandte Chemie should have that title, but most people I know only publish in Angewandte after JACS has rejected their paper.
Actual publication is still a far way off. I suppose I am at the stage that can be considered "2nd draft". There will be a 3rd draft after the co-authors have their say at which point it will be sent to the journal, which will send it out to referees for peer review. After the referees comment on it (assuming it is accepted) there will be a "1st revision" which will be sent back to the journal. The journal typesets the paper at which point it becomes a "Galley Proof" and then publication.
So it would seem that this particular battle with the English language has been won; however, while writing my own paper I have had to spend a lot of unfortunate time reading written reports for the class that I'm TA'ing. This battle has been largely lost I feel, and not solely because of the ESL students. The native speakers have acquired a keen disregard for all things grammatical and pay no mind to spelling or word choice. I try to focus on the English for the written reports because most of the time, their chemistry is even worse. This exercise has been thoroughly demoralizing. I threw away the standard rubric for a much more holistic grading scheme which consisted of "unacceptable" "needs improvement" and "satisfactory". So far only one student in 30 has received a grade of satisfactory.
With all this done I turn my attention to other matters. We have just received shipment of our new belt-drive vacuum pumps, which means that we can begin setting up the new Schlenk lines. Hopefully this will provide some material for the blog (including pictures for those of you who need some breaks from reading.)
January 21, 2008
The Chelate Effect
Teaching can be a disappointing enterprise. The other TA's and I worked fairly hard on updating a lab procedure to eliminate a lot of the systematic error that was persistent in the lab. I taught this same course last year in this same semester, so I was pretty familiar with what went wrong. The procedure is pretty simple: you make up some electrochemical copper cells and then measure the voltages at various temperatures. Plot the data and you can get delH, del S, Keq, del G and all this fantastic information. Although that last comment carries a whiff of sarcasm, this lab is pretty instructional if you don't screw it up. In spite of our best efforts to idiot-proof the lab, a substantial amount of idiotic data remains. As you can see from the plot below, the AB and BC data points are quite similar to what a grouping might look like for an epileptic firing a shotgun. (What we're looking for is more like the grouping of an epileptic firing an Uzi, preferably in one big spasm.) The R^2 value is supposed to indicate roughly the goodness of fit for the data. An R^2 of 1 is the gold standard, but 0.90 or up is good for this lab. As you can see, we have missed by an order of magnitude. Idiots.
January 8, 2008
Start
Another new year, another new semester. New classes to teach and new students whose names I have to learn. This bunch looks so-so. I haven't given up on them yet. There was a no-show but it was followed with a quick email lamenting some contagious disease. All in all a good first day. No blood, no broken glass, and no health and safety forms to fill out.
I'm going to try to make a better effort for regular posts. Things have been slow lately, and without pictures or some other medium to express my thoughts this blog can get very tedious to read I'm sure.
Prof. Heller has been in kind of a sour mood lately, which prevents retelling stories of his humorous anecdotes. He did happen into the lab during a conversation about biathlons. "The Finns are great at that. They had a lot of practice shooting Russians."
I've been browsing Ebay for a digital camera that I can keep in the lab on a somewhat permanent basis, to aide pictures for the blog. Hopefully that will come to fruition. Until then...
I'm going to try to make a better effort for regular posts. Things have been slow lately, and without pictures or some other medium to express my thoughts this blog can get very tedious to read I'm sure.
Prof. Heller has been in kind of a sour mood lately, which prevents retelling stories of his humorous anecdotes. He did happen into the lab during a conversation about biathlons. "The Finns are great at that. They had a lot of practice shooting Russians."
I've been browsing Ebay for a digital camera that I can keep in the lab on a somewhat permanent basis, to aide pictures for the blog. Hopefully that will come to fruition. Until then...
December 5, 2007
Harry Potter
Towards the end of the semester is notebook check time for those lucky TA's who happen to be teaching organic chemistry. Labmate Mark is one such lucky duck. I held the door open for him as he walked in with a stack of about 30 notebooks of various sizes and shapes. One notebook in particular caught my eye, as it had gold edging on it. After Mark set the notebooks down on his desk, I picked up the gold-edged notebook to have a better look. It was a Hogwarts School notebook replete with all the appropriate Harry Potter insignia and crazy little fake medieval pictrograms. This particular notebook was from the Gryffindor house. At this point I was impressed with this students dedication to her fantasy niche, but the icing on the cake came when I flipped to the front of the book to see the name. I'm omitting the actual name to spare further embarrassment if this person ever grows up.
Jane Doe, aspiring wizard
Gryffindor House, 2nd Year
Potions Class, section AC
After all this snickering I do have to admit that this girls notebook was immaculate, probably the best kept notebook in the section. If you need to pretend that you're a student wizard to maintain your interest in organic chemistry, then I guess that's just fine with me.
Jane Doe, aspiring wizard
Gryffindor House, 2nd Year
Potions Class, section AC
After all this snickering I do have to admit that this girls notebook was immaculate, probably the best kept notebook in the section. If you need to pretend that you're a student wizard to maintain your interest in organic chemistry, then I guess that's just fine with me.
December 3, 2007
Period Reports
It seems as though I've come to a point in my education when there is an extreme emphasis on writing and not so much on mixing chemical A with B. We've been recently notified that our funding agency is willing to grant us some more money. This is good news. The bad news is that they are holding this money ransom until we turn in our delinquent period report which was due a month ago. Prof. Heller has not told me how much money there is at stake here, but its clear that there is just enough that he's willing to have someone else write the report for him and turn it in, no questions asked. I've written 4 such reports since I've been here (more on the topic of scientific writing later) and it really is a joke. The amount of progress which is actually made on the chemistry is painfully small. The first time I was to write the report I just assumed it was OK to delete the old news and fill in the new results. Not so, I learned, as the funding weinies apparently can notice that the background and strategy sections are the same, so they just assume that you've done no work. Its much more effective to rewrite the entire document even if you provide absolutely no new results with a slightly different word order. The bean counters glance at the document, realize the paragraph sizes have changed, then send off the check. This certainly says something about the capabilities of those who hold the purse strings.
Since I'm not the only one on the budget, these excersices involve compiling the reports of my coworkers. The quality of writing is poor to say the least, partially out of apathy, but mosly out of not being able to effectively communicate. The common public perception of science writing is that it is dry and boring. I categorically agree with this, however, good science writing clearly conveys a message, and boring tediuousness like grammar is essential. It becomes much more tedious when correcting the grammar of others.
I've been request to teach a lab course which carries a writing credit on the undergraduates transcripts for next semester. I'm sure I'll have much more to say on the topic of writing in science after I start to read some of their reports.
Since I'm not the only one on the budget, these excersices involve compiling the reports of my coworkers. The quality of writing is poor to say the least, partially out of apathy, but mosly out of not being able to effectively communicate. The common public perception of science writing is that it is dry and boring. I categorically agree with this, however, good science writing clearly conveys a message, and boring tediuousness like grammar is essential. It becomes much more tedious when correcting the grammar of others.
I've been request to teach a lab course which carries a writing credit on the undergraduates transcripts for next semester. I'm sure I'll have much more to say on the topic of writing in science after I start to read some of their reports.
March 15, 2007
Student Grades
Well, grades are in for the class I'm a TA for. As you can see from the neatly constructed histogram, there are some winners and there are some losers in this bunch.
I don't know if it's luck of the draw, or actual TA influence, but the three high grades are from my section, and the three low grades are not. I'd like to think I personally had something to do with it, but I fear that the sample size isn't large enough to get too snobby. I'll wait to see what the TA evaluations look like before making any more presumptuous claims.
I don't know if it's luck of the draw, or actual TA influence, but the three high grades are from my section, and the three low grades are not. I'd like to think I personally had something to do with it, but I fear that the sample size isn't large enough to get too snobby. I'll wait to see what the TA evaluations look like before making any more presumptuous claims.
March 8, 2007
Exam proctoring
The class for which I TA had their exam today. I helped Prof. Heller out by going over the exam questions ahead of time, just to make sure that the poor little babies weren't overly challenged. (We wouldn't want to hurt their confidence going into exam week, now would we?)
For one of the questions, Heller wanted to use some data that was actually obtained by one of the students in the class. I dug it up for him but it wasn't exactly to his liking. "Do you think you could find a spectrum which has minor impurity peaks in it?" I told him I couldn't, but I said I would have no problem inventing the data in excel and producing a fake spectrum which was indistinguishable from the real thing. This is apparently not something your PhD adviser likes to hear, although he wasn't so appalled as to not use the spectrum. It was a little frightening how easy it was to make a plausible looking spectrum from completely falsified data. A test for the reader....three of the following spectra are real, the fourth is invented. Can you tell the difference? (click on the image to enlarge it)
For one of the questions, Heller wanted to use some data that was actually obtained by one of the students in the class. I dug it up for him but it wasn't exactly to his liking. "Do you think you could find a spectrum which has minor impurity peaks in it?" I told him I couldn't, but I said I would have no problem inventing the data in excel and producing a fake spectrum which was indistinguishable from the real thing. This is apparently not something your PhD adviser likes to hear, although he wasn't so appalled as to not use the spectrum. It was a little frightening how easy it was to make a plausible looking spectrum from completely falsified data. A test for the reader....three of the following spectra are real, the fourth is invented. Can you tell the difference? (click on the image to enlarge it)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)